Bad animation

What is bad animation? The answers cannot be crystal clear. Why? Because animation, like painting or photography, is an art, an expression of the artist.

There are many ways of doing animation, for example, one would have to go about TV show animation and feature film animation differently as both use different methods of animating. Limited and full animation. Does making animation with less frames or less key poses mean that it is bad animation? Not necessarily. Japanese animation is famous for its animation techniques. Not being able to animate like a Walt Disney Feature film does not make you any less an animator. Lots of stop motion animation looks jerky, does that make it bad?

How would one begin to judge what is bad animation? If you look at every aspect of an entire film or TV show, maybe then you could form an opinion saying “Yeah that sucks because I didn’t like the way the character died”. But that is not referring to the actual animation, rather the story. When learning animation its easy to spot what you like and don’t like and what seems to break the reality of movement. And that is the point of animation – making movement. So if something in an animation is not making the viewer convinced that the characters are living, then is that bad animation? Or is it incorrect technique? Two drawn mouths for lip sync in Japanese Animation breaks reality, but does that make anime bad animation? Apparently not.

As long as you are convinced something is moving, you do not necessarily have good animation. The author is the first that should be convinced by his or her work. He or she must think that what has been created is really happening, not real but really. If the animator is not feeling it, then it is bad animation. If the animator is in love with the imagery, the movements and the plot, then it should work.

There is no clear way to judge animation. Everyone has his or her own opinion. I think that if the artist has managed to convey their message across to the viewer by means of a life-like character, one that the audience can fall in love with, they have succeeded to cross various barriers of bad animation.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in animation and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Bad animation

  1. The only thing I can think of that would fall into that category is the way ‘animators’ tend to let their egos and fame lead them. Animation is serious, tedious work, and often, most go by way of hiring more people to do their work for them, instead of using their own skills.

    Nowadays, animation work here are mostly outsourced -stuff we do for others. That will change, since I’m one of those who are writing and creating our own content.

    Very timely article. Hope to fit in to the ‘Good’ animation category.

    • wholebit says:

      So what you are saying is that if the animator through their own skill manages to make something look lifelike it is a successful animation. But not only are there many hands on an animated character there are also a lot of computers doing the work of animation.

      There has always been a dispute as to whether the tools were good enough to pull of the work of creating lifelike characters. Now that the tools are here, it seems as if we exist in a blind alley of self delusion as to whether what we’ve been given truly is able to cummunicate a truly engaging experience for the viewers.

      When side by side with what has gone before, it appears as if the tools are doing more of the work, as was always expected. But is that better? Most will at least admit that the previous styles are at least as good as what were seeing now.

      I think that CG animators are aware of this subconciously and tend to overcompensate by exxageration of the movements in a way that has become the new norm. Sorry if you disagree tho! I too am wrestling the computer to realize animations.

      Please see my site: http://www.wholebitmedia.com

      • I totally agree… Everything is basically done for us, and not only with animation but in most facets of life. We rely too much on the tools that are set before us and sometimes lose touch with our own creativity and capabilities.

        Thanks for the comment ^_^

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s